Discussion about this post

User's avatar
DiverDave's avatar

Not funnaaaaay!

This writer, a history teacher, needs to go back to school. He needs to polish up not only on his history, but also on his deportment. This snide little tale should be sent to time out.

Perhaps the author is a captive of business-as-usual Washington, DC. “The usual” in DC is personified by former-Speaker Pelosi. She whipped her minions into shape in advance of any floor debate over her leadership. Her Speaker victory was by then a foregone conclusion. Think Stalin, and his dictatorship’s 100% victory margins in their elections. Also, was it possible for a rookie Member to initiate a vote of no confidence against the previous Speaker (as they may do now under the new Speaker)? Nope. While she reigned, she was as immovable as the Kremlin’s Uncle Joe was.

This author makes fun of the 14 votes, leading up to Speaker McCarthy’s victory. As a small “d” democrat, I happen to support and promote elections, and voting freely. McCarthy’s election win was never a done deal. Democracy is not a done deal, either. It is worked out, through dialogue, and often via negotiation and dealmaking. That’s what I saw happening throughout those 14 votes.

The author’s suggestion that McCarthy is an appeaser, akin to British Prime Minister Chamberlain’s kowtowing to Adolf Hitler, is baseless hyperbole. The new Speaker and House GOP Members debated, negotiated, cut deals on their party’s legislative rules, policy planks and future legislative aims.

The writer doth protest too much, about democracy itself. To paraphrase a wise US politician, my advice to this wrong-way educator is: Fill out a “Hurt Feelings Report” and move on.

Expand full comment

No posts